In an attempt to both clean up my desk and alleviate the ergonomic nightmare that is my desk, I recently just bought an external keyboard/mouse set for my Mac – the Logitech S-530. You can see their PR spiel on it here: Manufacturer Product Link. I thought I’d share my experiences with it, partially because I want to get used to typing on it too
It may look familiar, but that’s because the product itself is basically the exact same thing as the S-510 keyboard set with the exception that it has been Mac-customized and bundled with a much better mouse (MX600 laser as opposed to some optical mouse). Unfortunately for Mac consumers, both Microsoft and Logitech consider a regular PC keyboard that’s been dressed up with more typical Mac stylings to be a good enough effort, and that’s no different here. Fortunately, you only notice this in a few areas.
Setup is pretty simple, as with most things USB. You unpack the kit, remove the cellophane and plastic wrappers, insert the batteries, and plug in the USB stick. It comes with a dongle USB extension if you want to bring out the receiver to somewhere more accessible (useful for Mac Pro or iMacs with crowded USB ports in the back), but it’s optional. It’s important to note that the USB receiver is not of the newer 2.4GHz or Bluetooth variety that other keyboard sets from Logitech have. This might not be super important, but if you’re looking to use it over tens of feet this could be a problem.
The mouse is great. It’s got a laser sensor, which works about as well as all their other laser mouse (read: it does well). It’s hard to tell from the press photos, but the body is actually silver plastic with white plastic on the sides. I guess they were trying to hedge their bets when it came to iMac/MacBook consumers vs. Mac/MacBook Pro consumers. Mouse tracking is okay, but a little sluggish. Definitely a step down in smoothness compared to my old wired MX510, and maybe the 2.4GHz wireless VX200 too. I’m going to blame the wireless receiver again.
Now for the big reason I bought this set: the keyboard. The keys aren’t completely like laptop-style flat keys, but more like typical keycaps with a bit of depth to them. As some Amazon reviewers noted, not all the shortcut buttons on the side are perfectly aligned; my Mail shortcut key is tiled at about a -20ยบ angle. In all honesty, it’s not a big deal.
Here’s where the fact that this is a restyled PC keyboard comes in: the command key is simply a Windows-style Alt key with a different label on it. Ditto for the option key – it’s a relabeled Windows key. You can sort of see this in the press photos for the S510. Why is this important? The left command key is a little harder to get at because it’s not as close to your left thumb and smaller than on an Apple-branded keyboard. To see what I mean, look any Apple Keyboard – notice that the Command key extends from the interior edge of Z all the way to the edge of X. By contrast, a Windows key/Logitech Command key stops somewhere in the middle of the X key. That being said, I can deal with the command key being shorter – it’ll just take getting a little used to. Here’s to hoping that Logitech or Microsoft produce a keyboard for Mac users that has its own subtly different keyboard layout, but I wouldn’t expect it because of the cost.
Even so, the effort is still pretty good. A lot of the usual Mac keyboard features are nicely placed on here. There’s special Eject and Brightness keys, in addition to the other keys on the side. The application keys work as promised, though the iPhoto icon doesn’t really look like iPhoto.
The keys aren’t super quiet – they have a bit of clackiness to them. They feel pretty good though, and aren’t too mushy.
Back to harping about the wireless: this keyboard has a bit of lag to it. It’s not too bad, but it is noticeable. I type at about a 70-80 wpm on average and I can notice it.
Overall, I’d give this keyboard and mouse a 6.5 out of 10. Not perfect at all, but definitely has its advantages and still quite useful. I plan on keeping it as the cordless function is highly desirable for me, and I don’t feel like paying the $80 for the new Apple Bluetooth Keyboard and/or $30 for a different Logitech cordless mouse. I got it shipped from Amazon for $56
, and at that price it’s still a good deal (think of it as $28 for the keyboard and mouse each).